My Brother-in-Law Shot the Steer I’d Raised for Our Freezer, but What I Did With the Meat Surprised Everyone

“She asked me to tell you,” I said. “She said, Make sure he knows his name.”

Vern made a sound. Low. Like something breaking inside his chest.

He turned the box right side up. He held it against his stomach with both arms. The way Pete did.

“I didn’t know his name,” he said again.

“Why’d you do it, Vern?”

He didn’t answer for a long time.

He looked past me. Down the road. At our little white house a mile and a half away. At the pasture. At the fence corner where he’d stood with his rifle.

“Eighteen feet,” he said finally.

“The survey,” I said. “Dale told me.”

Vern nodded slowly.

“The bank sent a man out in July,” he said. “From Farm Credit in Ames. To appraise the land. For the loan.” He swallowed. “I’m behind, Jill. Two years. Corn was bad last year. Beans were worse. And Mom’s nursing home took everything before she died. Eleven months at Good Samaritan. Eighty-four hundred a month.”

I didn’t say anything.

“The appraiser said the acres don’t match,” Vern said. “Said the deed says two hundred and forty, but he could only find two hundred and thirty-eight. Said I’d better get a survey.” He shook his head. “So I did. Fourteen hundred dollars I didn’t have. And the surveyor said the fence is eighteen feet onto my side. All the way. That’s my two acres. That’s the difference.”

“I called Dale,” Vern said. “I asked him to move the fence. Just eighteen feet. Just so the bank would leave me alone.” He looked at the ground. “He said no. He said Dad put it there and it’s not moving.”

“So you shot Kinley’s steer.”

He flinched.

“I didn’t mean to,” he said. “I swear to God, Jill. I didn’t plan it. I got up that morning and there was another letter from Farm Credit. And I walked out to the end rows to check the corn because I can’t afford to combine it, I can’t afford the fuel. And I looked across that fence.”

He stopped.

“And there he was,” Vern said. “Eating grass. On my eighteen feet. Fat and happy. Dale’s steer on my land.” His voice broke. “And I had the rifle in the truck for coyotes. And I just…”

He couldn’t finish.

“He wasn’t Dale’s steer,” I said quietly. “He was Kinley’s. She fed him at five every morning before the school bus. For eight weeks. In the snow.”

Vern closed his eyes.

“I know,” he said. “I know that now. I’ve known it since Saturday. Since I watched her run across that pasture.” He opened his eyes. They were full. “I watched her from my window, Jill. I watched you catch her. I watched her sit down on your porch steps.”

He looked down at the box in his arms.

“I haven’t slept since,” he said. “Not one night.”

“Why didn’t you answer Dale?” I asked. “He called you twice.”

“Because I couldn’t,” Vern said. “What would I say? I shot your daughter’s steer because I’m losing my farm and I was mad at you about a fence our dad built?”

He laughed. A terrible, hollow sound.

“Lorraine’s gone,” he said. “My wife’s been gone six years. My boy’s in Denver and doesn’t call. I’ve got two hundred and thirty-eight acres of corn I can’t afford to combine and a bank that wants to take it. And my little brother’s got the home place and a wife and a daughter and a steer.”

He looked at me.

“I’ve never been so ashamed of anything in my life,” he said.

I didn’t say anything for a long time.

I’d been angry for two weeks. So angry I couldn’t sleep either. Angry while I bled that steer. Angry while I held my daughter on the porch steps. Angry while I drove the mail route past his mailbox every single day.

Standing there at the end of his lane, I was still angry.

But I looked at him. At his gray face and his messy hair and his shaking hands. Holding a box of beef with my daughter’s handwriting on the bottom.

And I thought about what my grandpa said. You don’t waste an animal. She gave her life. You make it count.

“Vern,” I said. “Do you want to tell her yourself?”

He looked up at me. Startled.

“She’s in the truck,” I said. “She asked me to tell you his name. But she’s right there.”

He looked past me at the pickup. At the passenger window. At Kinley’s face, behind the glass.

He was quiet for a long time.

“She won’t want to see me,” he said.

“I don’t know what she wants,” I said. “Ask her.”

Chapter Ten: Kinley

Vern walked to the pickup.

Slowly. With the box in his arms. He stopped beside the passenger door. He stood there for a long moment.

Kinley didn’t roll down the window. She looked at him through the glass. Her face didn’t move.

Then she opened the door.

She didn’t get out. She just opened it. And sat there in the passenger seat with her hands in her lap, looking at her uncle.

Vern stood there in the gravel. He held the box.

“Kinley,” he said.

She didn’t say anything.

“I shot your steer,” Vern said.

He said it plain. No excuses. I’ll give him that.

“I shot him, and I lied to your mom about why. He wasn’t in my corn. The fence was tight. Your dad built it right.” He swallowed. “I was angry at your dad about something that wasn’t Domino’s fault. And it wasn’t your fault. And I took it out on him.”

Kinley’s chin was shaking.

“I’m sorry,” Vern said. “I’m so sorry, honey. I know that doesn’t bring him back.”

Kinley looked at him for a long time.

Then she looked at the box in his arms. At the bottom of it. Where she’d written his name.

“Did you know he came when you called him?” she asked.

Vern shook his head.

“He did,” Kinley said. Her voice was very small. “Like a dog. If you stood at the gate and said Domino, he’d come running from the far end of the pasture. And he’d put his head against your chest and push.”

Vern’s face crumpled.

“He liked his ears scratched,” Kinley said. “Right here.” She touched the spot behind her own ear. “And he was scared of thunder. When there was a storm, he’d stand by the barn door till I came out.”

She was crying now. Quietly. Tears running down her face.

“I knew he was going to the locker,” she said. “I knew it. I’m not stupid. I live on a farm. I knew he was going to be our hamburger.” She wiped her face on her sleeve. “But I was going to say goodbye. On the twenty-sixth. I was going to walk him into the trailer myself and scratch his ears one more time and tell him he was a good boy.”

She looked up at her uncle.

“You took that,” she said. “That’s what you took. Not the beef. The goodbye.”

Vern couldn’t speak.

He stood there beside my pickup in the gravel with the box of beef in his arms and the wind blowing his gray hair. And he cried. Like I’d never seen a grown man cry. With his whole body. Shaking.

He didn’t wipe his face. He just stood there and let it come.

Kinley watched him.

Then my daughter did something I didn’t expect.

She got out of the pickup.

She stepped down onto the gravel in her rubber boots. She walked around the open door. She stood in front of her uncle.

She reached out and put her hand on the box. On top of it. On the white wax cardboard.

“His name was Domino,” she said.

“Domino,” Vern repeated.

“Say it like you mean it.”

Vern looked down at her.

“Domino,” he said. His voice broke in half on it.

Kinley nodded once.

“Okay,” she said. “Now you know who he was.”

Then she got back in the pickup and shut the door.

Vern stood there. He looked at me over the top of the cab.

“Jill,” he said. “I’ll pay for him. Eighteen hundred dollars. Every dime. I don’t have it now. But I’ll get it.”

“I don’t want your money, Vern,” I said.

“Then what do you want?”

I thought about it. About the eighteen feet. About the bank letters with FINAL NOTICE stamped in red. About two hundred and thirty-eight acres of corn rattling in the wind, unharvested at the end of October.

About Pete Larson. He knew right where the line was. He put it there on purpose.

“I want you and Dale to walk that fence,” I said. “Together. Sunday afternoon. And I want you to take Pete Larson with you.”

Chapter Eleven: The Fence

They walked it on Sunday.

Dale got home from Dubuque Saturday night. I told him everything. The boxes. The porches. Vern at the end of his lane. Kinley getting out of the pickup.

He sat at the kitchen table for a long time after I finished. He didn’t say anything.

Then he picked up the phone. And called his brother.

Vern answered on the first ring.

Sunday afternoon. Two o’clock. Gray and cold, with a little spit of rain.

Dale and Vern and Pete Larson met at the road end of the fence. I watched from the kitchen window. Kinley watched from her bedroom.

Three men in canvas coats and feed caps, walking a fence line in the drizzle. Pete in the middle, with his cane. Dale on one side, Vern on the other.

They walked the whole half mile. Slowly. Pete stopped at every post. He’d put his hand on it and say something. Dale and Vern would lean in to listen.

At the corner, where Domino died, they stopped for a long time.

Dale told me afterward. At the kitchen table that night.

“Pete knew,” he said. “About the eighteen feet. He’s always known. He helped Dad set those posts in ‘72.”

“What did he say?”

“He said Dad put it there on purpose,” Dale said. “He said Dad knew exactly where the surveyed line was. It runs right through a low spot by the creek. Floods every spring. Dad didn’t want to fence through a slough. So he set it eighteen feet north, on high ground.” He shook his head. “And he told Pete, someday I’ll fix the deed so it matches. And he never did.”

“So Vern’s right,” I said. “Technically.”

“On paper,” Dale said. “On the survey. But Pete says there’s a thing in Iowa law. When a fence has been there long enough, and both sides treat it as the line, it becomes the line. Even if the survey says different.”

“Acquiescence,” I said. I knew that word. I deliver a lot of mail to the lawyers in Plainview.

“That’s it,” Dale said. “Pete says after ten years in Iowa, a fence everybody’s lived by is the boundary. Fifty years, there’s no question. That eighteen feet is ours. Legally.”

He looked at me across the table.

“And then he told Vern something,” Dale said. “Pete did. Right there at the corner where Domino died.”

“What?”

“He said, your daddy put that fence on the high ground so his cattle wouldn’t drown in the slough. And he put it on your side because he figured you boys would always be on the same side of it anyway.”

Dale put his face in his hands.

“Vern sat down in the grass,” he said. “Right there in the corner. In the rain. Fifty-three years old. And he cried like a kid.”

“And you?”

“I sat down next to him,” Dale said.

They went to see a lawyer in Plainview the next week. Both of them. Together.

Her name was Rachel Ostrem. She does farm law. She’s been doing it thirty years.

She drew up a boundary line agreement. A legal document saying the fence is the line. Both brothers signed it. She filed it with the county recorder. She sent a copy to Farm Credit in Ames.

Then she did something else. Something Dale told her to do.

“I bought the two acres,” Dale told me that night. “From Vern. The eighteen feet.”

“Bought them? I thought they were ours already. Legally.”

“They are,” Dale said. “But Vern needed it in the books. For the bank. The appraiser said two hundred and forty acres. So now the deed shows two hundred and thirty-eight, and the bank knows why. And Vern’s got the money for those two acres.” He looked at the table. “Eleven thousand dollars. At fair value. Rachel figured it.”

I stared at him.

“We don’t have eleven thousand dollars, Dale.”

“We do,” he said quietly. “It’s my truck-driving money. From harvest. I was saving it for a new pickup.”

“Dale…”

“He’s my brother, Jill,” Dale said. “I’ve got a pickup that runs. He’s got a bank that wants his farm.”

Then, on the first Monday in November, at seven in the morning, I looked out the kitchen window.

There were combines in Vern’s corn.

Three of them. Coming down the rows in a line. A green John Deere. A red Case. And a yellow-and-green one I didn’t recognize.

And grain carts. And semis lined up at the end of Vern’s lane.

I knew the combines. The green one was Pete Larson’s. The red one was the Brennans’. The yellow-and-green one belonged to Tomas Molina, Rosa’s husband, who custom-harvested on weekends.

Dale was driving a grain cart.

I called him on his cell phone.

“Dale,” I said. “What is going on?”

“Pete called everybody,” Dale said. “Saturday night. After he walked the fence with us. He said Vern couldn’t afford to combine.” I could hear the engine. “So everybody on Hollow Creek Road is combining it for him. Fuel’s on the co-op. Arnold Fogle donated it.”

“Arnold?”

“Arnold,” Dale said. “He said Domino would’ve wanted it.”

Chapter Twelve: The Last Box

They had Vern’s corn in by Tuesday night.

Two hundred and thirty-eight acres. A hundred and ninety-one bushels an acre. Better than anybody expected. Vern sold it at the elevator in Plainview for enough to catch up the Farm Credit payments. Not all the way. But enough. The bank gave him a new note.

He tried to pay everybody back for the combining. Nobody would take it.

Pete Larson told him the same thing everybody else did.

“Harold helped me in ‘81,” Pete said. “When my barn burned. I’m just paying it back.”

Vern came to our house the Saturday before Thanksgiving.

He knocked on the back door. Dale was home. Kinley was at the kitchen table doing homework.

Vern stood on the back step in his canvas coat. He was holding a white waxed box.

His box. The one with DOMINO on the bottom.

“I haven’t opened it,” he said. “I couldn’t.”

He came in. He set the box on the kitchen table, in front of Kinley.

See more on the next page

 

Leave a Comment